The Protiviti View  | Insights From Our Experts on Trends, Risks and Opportunities

The Protiviti View

Insights From Our Experts on Trends, Risks and Opportunities

ARTICLE

2 mins to read

CECL/IFRS 9 Update: New Credit Impairment Model Deadlines and Implementation Considerations

Wall Street sign on street post
Larger Font
2 minutes to read

As Protiviti reported back in May, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) and the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) have been looking for lessons in the global banking crisis of 2007-08 and have come up with new forward-looking predictive models for financial institutions to use when estimating how much to reserve against potential loan losses.

The FASB’s CECL model will become effective in 2020, with the IASB’s International Financial Reporting Standard 9 (IFRS 9) standard beginning that year if early adoption is not elected. Protiviti strongly recommends immediate action because of the extensive changes in data-collection practices, systems configuration, loan classification and risk modeling required by the change.

The new impairment model from FASB, which applies to banks, savings and loans, credit unions, and non-bank lenders in the United States, and global institutions traded on U.S. exchanges, is called Current Expected Credit Loss (CECL). Final guidance on the model was issued on June 16, 2016. The new impairment model from IASB, which applies to institutions based outside the United States, is a part of IFRS.

For a detailed analysis of these new methodologies, see Protiviti’s Point of View briefing, Impact of the New Current Expected Credit Loss (CECL) Methodology, and the companion paper, IFRS 9 Impairment — Practical Implications. Both models are discussed, along with implementation considerations, in our Aug. 17 webinar, “Impact and Challenges of CECL and IFRS,” available in our online webinar archive.

The methodologies are similar in that they both replace traditional reserve requirements based on historical losses with new predictive models incorporating past, present and future data, as well as market intelligence and macroeconomic trends. The primary difference is that IFRS 9 uses a three-stage loan classification model not included in CECL.

The basics of these two methodologies have been covered in our previous blog post, so we don’t want to rehash them here, but we do want to share some implementation considerations we discussed in the webinar. Successful implementation is going to require an enterprisewide effort with input from most, if not all, departments. Some of the bigger details to be worked out include:

  • Gathering required data assets/history to feed the new model requirements
  • Creating underlying models and IT infrastructure for determining the required reserves
  • Identifying required business process updates, along with resources required to validate the updated reserving methodologies

Specific deadlines for CECL include:

  • SEC filing institutions effective for years beginning after Dec. 15, 2019
  • Non-SEC filing public business entities effective for years beginning after Dec. 15, 2020
  • All other entities, plus nonprofit organizations, effective for fiscal years beginning after Dec. 15, 2020, and interim periods with fiscal years beginning Dec. 15, 2021

IFRS 9 is effective for all entities for annual periods beginning on or after Jan. 1, 2018, but firms may choose to adopt the standard early.

Protiviti is already working closely with clients to help them prepare, and we encourage all financial institutions to act without delay. We fully expect practical issues and questions to be raised during the implementation and auditing phases, and further evolution of the guidance is quite likely. Financial service organizations need to start assessing the implications of these approaches sooner rather than later.

Protiviti Associate Director Benjamin Shiu contributed to our CECL and IFRS 9 materials as well as our webinar.

Was this article helpful to you?

Thanks for your feedback!

Subscribe to The Protiviti View Blog

To face the future confidently, you need to be equipped with valuable insights that align with your interests and business goals.

In this Article

Authors

Charlie Anderson

By Charlie Anderson

Verified Expert at Protiviti

EXPERTISE

Charles Soranno

By Charles Soranno

Verified Expert at Protiviti

Charles is a Managing Director in New York with extensive experience in IPOs, technical accounting and SEC reporting,...

EXPERTISE

No noise.
Just insights.

Subscribe now

Related articles

Article

What is it about

As the stakes increase for ensuring the integrity of sustainability reports, CFOs across all industries should not only consider adding...

Article

What is it about

Adapting new technologies to manufacturing applications and processes is often a challenge – and, particularly with AI, there is no...

Article

What is it about

What you need to know: Marking a new era for the accounting of renewable energy sources and energy-storage facilities, regulated...